All recipes

Paneer Butter Masala

Paneer in creamy butter gravy

पनीर बटर मसाला

paneer = cheese, butter masala = buttery spice gravy

Paneer Butter Masala
Active
~50 min
Yield
Spice blend
Chicken Butter Masala mix — same family as
Pairs with
, .
Start Cook Mode

Your recipe, kept as written. The gravy is the vegetarian twin of .

Ingredients — gravy

  • ½ tsp grated or 6 whole pods
  • 5 red , chopped
  • 3 large garlic cloves
  • ½ tsp or fresh ginger
  • 4 × 400 g cans chopped tomatoes (~240 g drained each)
  • 2 tsp salt
  • 34 g Chicken Butter Masala mix
  • 1 tsp
  • 30
  • 2 tsp sugar
  • water for blending

Ingredients — paneer

  • 1 kg , cubed
  • 2–3 tbsp butter
  • 1–2
  • small
  • a few pods

To finish

  • 4 tsp , crushed
  • 1 can coconut milk or (optional)
  • a splash of on top (optional)

Steps

  1. 1. onions, garlic, cardamom, ginger until the onions turn pink/soft.
  2. 2.Add the tomatoes, salt, the Chicken Butter Masala mix, Kashmiri chili, cashews and sugar. Cook ~3 min.
  3. 3.Add a little water; . Strain if needed.
  4. 4.In a second pan, melt butter, bay/cinnamon/cardamom, then .
  5. 5.Pour the gravy over the paneer; mix. over the top. Simmer 2 min.
  6. 6.Stir in coconut milk or cream if using. Float a last splash of cream on top; garnish with coriander.

Scaling table

Ingredient8–10 people3–4 people
Paneer1 kg350 g
Butter2–3 tbsp1 tbsp
Bay leaves1–21
Cinnamon1 small piece1 small piece
Green cardamom6 pods (or ½ tsp grated)2 pods (or ⅙ tsp grated)
Red onions52
Garlic3 cloves1 large
Ginger powder½ tsp⅙ tsp (a pinch)
Chopped tomatoes4 cans (240 g drained each)1⅓ cans (~320 g drained)
Salt2 tsp¾ tsp
Chicken Butter Masala mix34 g11 g
Kashmiri chili1 tsp⅓ tsp
Cashews3010
Sugar2 tsp⅔ tsp
Kasuri methi4 tsp1⅓ tsp
Coconut milk / cream1 can / to tasteto taste

Variations

From scratch (no packet): use the homemade blend — same flavour family.
Shahi Paneer / Paneer Makhani: richer, milder cousins.

This is the dish that lets vegetarians eat at the butter-chicken table — the same rich tomato-cashew gravy, with fried paneer carrying the sauce instead of meat. The two dried-fenugreek touches at the end are what make it smell like a restaurant.